From 8e3fee33afed8cb6a0945288f4773363a4d68912 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Zbigniew Jędrzejewski-Szmek Date: Fri, 23 Feb 2024 09:48:47 +0100 Subject: Revert "docs: use collections to structure the data" This reverts commit 5e8ff010a1436d33bbf3c108335af6e0b4ff7a2a. This broke all the URLs, we can't have that. (And actually, we probably don't _want_ to make the change either. It's nicer to have all the pages in one directory, so one doesn't have to figure out to which collection the page belongs.) --- docs/FILE_DESCRIPTOR_STORE.md | 213 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 213 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/FILE_DESCRIPTOR_STORE.md (limited to 'docs/FILE_DESCRIPTOR_STORE.md') diff --git a/docs/FILE_DESCRIPTOR_STORE.md b/docs/FILE_DESCRIPTOR_STORE.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..206dda7038 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/FILE_DESCRIPTOR_STORE.md @@ -0,0 +1,213 @@ +--- +title: File Descriptor Store +category: Interfaces +layout: default +SPDX-License-Identifier: LGPL-2.1-or-later +--- + +# The File Descriptor Store + +*TL;DR: The systemd service manager may optionally maintain a set of file +descriptors for each service. Those file descriptors are under control of the +service. Storing file descriptors in the manager makes is easier to restart +services without dropping connections or losing state.* + +Since its inception `systemd` has supported the *socket* *activation* +mechanism: the service manager creates and listens on some sockets (and similar +UNIX file descriptors) on behalf of a service, and then passes them to the +service during activation of the service via UNIX file descriptor (short: *fd*) +passing over `execve()`. This is primarily exposed in the +[.socket](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/systemd.socket.html) +unit type. + +The *file* *descriptor* *store* (short: *fdstore*) extends this concept, and +allows services to *upload* during runtime additional fds to the service +manager that it shall keep on its behalf. File descriptors are passed back to +the service on subsequent activations, the same way as any socket activation +fds are passed. + +If a service fd is passed to the fdstore logic of the service manager it only +maintains a duplicate of it (in the sense of UNIX +[`dup(2)`](https://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man2/dup.2.html)), the fd remains +also in possession of the service itself, and it may (and is expected to) +invoke any operations on it that it likes. + +The primary use-case of this logic is to permit services to restart seamlessly +(for example to update them to a newer version), without losing execution +context, dropping pinned resources, terminating established connections or even +just momentarily losing connectivity. In fact, as the file descriptors can be +uploaded freely at any time during the service runtime, this can even be used +to implement services that robustly handle abnormal termination and can recover +from that without losing pinned resources. + +Note that Linux supports the +[`memfd`](https://man7.org/linux/man-pages/man2/memfd_create.2.html) concept +that allows associating a memory-backed fd with arbitrary data. This may +conveniently be used to serialize service state into and then place in the +fdstore, in order to implement service restarts with full service state being +passed over. + +## Basic Mechanism + +The fdstore is enabled per-service via the +[`FileDescriptorStoreMax=`](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/systemd.service.html#FileDescriptorStoreMax=) +service setting. It defaults to zero (which means the fdstore logic is turned +off), but can take an unsigned integer value that controls how many fds to +permit the service to upload to the service manager to keep simultaneously. + +If set to values > 0, the fdstore is enabled. When invoked the service may now +(asynchronously) upload file descriptors to the fdstore via the +[`sd_pid_notify_with_fds()`](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/sd_pid_notify_with_fds.html) +API call (or an equivalent re-implementation). When uploading the fds it is +necessary to set the `FDSTORE=1` field in the message, to indicate what the fd +is intended for. It's recommended to also set the `FDNAME=…` field to any +string of choice, which may be used to identify the fd later. + +Whenever the service is restarted the fds in its fdstore will be passed to the +new instance following the same protocol as for socket activation fds. i.e. the +`$LISTEN_FDS`, `$LISTEN_PIDS`, `$LISTEN_FDNAMES` environment variables will be +set (the latter will be populated from the `FDNAME=…` field mentioned +above). See +[`sd_listen_fds()`](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/sd_listen_fds.html) +for details on receiving such fds in a service. (Note that the name set in +`FDNAME=…` does not need to be unique, which is useful when operating with +multiple fully equivalent sockets or similar, for example for a service that +both operates on IPv4 and IPv6 and treats both more or less the same.). + +And that's already the gist of it. + +## Seamless Service Restarts + +A system service that provides a client-facing interface that shall be able to +seamlessly restart can make use of this in a scheme like the following: +whenever a new connection comes in it uploads its fd immediately into its +fdstore. At appropriate times it also serializes its state into a memfd it +uploads to the service manager — either whenever the state changed +sufficiently, or simply right before it terminates. (The latter of course means +that state only survives on *clean* restarts and abnormal termination implies the +state is lost completely — while the former would mean there's a good chance the +next restart after an abnormal termination could continue where it left off +with only some context lost.) + +Using the fdstore for such seamless service restarts is generally recommended +over implementations that attempt to leave a process from the old service +instance around until after the new instance already started, so that the old +then communicates with the new service instance, and passes the fds over +directly. Typically service restarts are a mechanism for implementing *code* +updates, hence leaving two version of the service running at the same time is +generally problematic. It also collides with the systemd service manager's +general principle of guaranteeing a pristine execution environment, a pristine +security context, and a pristine resource management context for freshly +started services, without uncontrolled "leftovers" from previous runs. For +example: leaving processes from previous runs generally negatively affects +lifecycle management (i.e. `KillMode=none` must be set), which disables large +parts of the service managers state tracking, resource management (as resource +counters cannot start at zero during service activation anymore, since the old +processes remaining skew them), security policies (as processes with possibly +out-of-date security policies – SElinux, AppArmor, any LSM, seccomp, BPF — in +effect remain), and similar. + +## File Descriptor Store Lifecycle + +By default any file descriptor stored in the fdstore for which a `POLLHUP` or +`POLLERR` is seen is automatically closed and removed from the fdstore. This +behavior can be turned off, by setting the `FDPOLL=0` field when uploading the +fd via `sd_notify_with_fds()`. + +The fdstore is automatically closed whenever the service is fully deactivated +and no jobs are queued for it anymore. This means that a restart job for a +service will leave the fdstore intact, but a separate stop and start job for +it — executed synchronously one after the other — will likely not. + +This behavior can be modified via the +[`FileDescriptorStorePreserve=`](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/systemd.service.html#FileDescriptorStorePreserve=) +setting in service unit files. If set to `yes` the fdstore will be kept as long +as the service definition is loaded into memory by the service manager, i.e. as +long as at least one other loaded unit has a reference to it. + +The `systemctl clean --what=fdstore …` command may be used to explicitly clear +the fdstore of a service. This is only allowed when the service is fully +deactivated, and is hence primarily useful in case +`FileDescriptorStorePreserve=yes` is set (because the fdstore is otherwise +fully closed anyway in this state). + +Individual file descriptors may be removed from the fdstore via the +`sd_notify()` mechanism, by sending an `FDSTOREREMOVE=1` message, accompanied +by an `FDNAME=…` string identifying the fds to remove. (The name does not have +to be unique, as mentioned, in which case *all* matching fds are +closed). Generally it's a good idea to send such messages to the service +manager during initialization of the service whenever an unrecognized fd is +received, to make the service robust for code updates: if an old version +uploaded an fd that the new version doesn't recognize anymore it's good idea to +close it both in the service and in the fdstore. + +Note that storing a duplicate of an fd in the fdstore means the resource pinned +by the fd remains pinned even if the service closes its duplicate of the +fd. This in particular means that peers on a connection socket uploaded this +way will not receive an automatic `POLLHUP` event anymore if the service code +issues `close()` on the socket. It must accompany it with an `FDSTOREREMOVE=1` +notification to the service manager, so that the fd is comprehensively closed. + +## Access Control + +Access to the fds in the file descriptor store is generally restricted to the +service code itself. Pushing fds into or removing fds from the fdstore is +subject to the access control restrictions of any other `sd_notify()` message, +which is controlled via +[`NotifyAccess=`](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/systemd.service.html#NotifyAccess=). + +By default only the main service process hence can push/remove fds, but by +setting `NotifyAccess=all` this may be relaxed to allow arbitrary service +child processes to do the same. + +## Soft Reboot + +The fdstore is particularly interesting in [soft +reboot](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/systemd-soft-reboot.service.html) +scenarios, as per `systemctl soft-reboot` (which restarts userspace like in a +real reboot, but leaves the kernel running). File descriptor stores that remain +loaded at the very end of the system cycle — just before the soft-reboot – are +passed over to the next system cycle, and propagated to services they originate +from there. This enables updating the full userspace of a system during +runtime, fully replacing all processes without losing pinning resources, +interrupting connectivity or established connections and similar. + +This mechanism can be enabled either by making sure the service survives until +the very end (i.e. by setting `DefaultDependencies=no` so that it keeps running +for the whole system lifetime without being regularly deactivated at shutdown) +or by setting `FileDescriptorStorePreserve=yes` (and referencing the unit +continuously). + +For further details see [Resource +Pass-Through](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/systemd-soft-reboot.service.html#Resource%20Pass-Through). + +## Initrd Transitions + +The fdstore may also be used to pass file descriptors for resources from the +initrd context to the main system. Restarting all processes after the +transition is important as code running in the initrd should generally not +continue to run after the switch to the host file system, since that pins +backing files from the initrd, and the initrd might contain different versions +of programs than the host. + +Any service that still runs during the initrd→host transition will have its +fdstore passed over the transition, where it will be passed back to any queued +services of the same name. + +The soft reboot cycle transition and the initrd→host transition are +semantically very similar, hence similar rules apply, and in both cases it is +recommended to use the fdstore if pinned resources shall be passed over. + +## Debugging + +The +[`systemd-analyze`](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/systemd-analyze.html#systemd-analyze%20fdstore%20%5BUNIT...%5D) +tool may be used to list the current contents of the fdstore of any running +service. + +The +[`systemd-run`](https://www.freedesktop.org/software/systemd/man/systemd-run.html) +tool may be used to quickly start a testing binary or similar as a service. Use +`-p FileDescriptorStore=4711` to enable the fdstore from `systemd-run`'s +command line. By using the `-t` switch you can even interactively communicate +via processes spawned that way, via the TTY. -- cgit v1.2.3